Montag, 18. April 2016

Blog assignment 2: Material and methods



Blog assignment 2: Material and methods

Tree nursery Schinznach – Where could irrigation water be economised? 
How much water is seeping through the plastic foil?

Good water management is a fundamental task in a tree nursery. Exaggerated irrigation causes more than simply unecessary runoff. Most pesticides are applied in a water-based carrier through the irrigation system, so some of these chemicals will end up in the wastewater runoff.  (Dumroese, P.197) To avoid excessive runoff therefore helps to keep the stored irrigation water as clean as possible while reducing the water circulation effort. To avoid a contamination of groundwater and surrounding soil and for economising ground water and fertilizer use , the irrigation system should be as leakproof as possible.  
In the last blog entry I gave a large overview of which and how data to this research topic could be collected. In this post I describe more detailed how we could apply the mentioned methods in our project week to collect significant data.

In this research topic the amounts of rainfall, irrigation, drainage and soil moisture data need to be determined. Based on the following water balance equation we can determine the specific amounts.

PI + SW - RO - D - ET = 0

PI
Precipitation and/or irrigation
RO
Runoff
D
Deep percolation
SW
Change in soil moisture
ET
Evapotranspiration

(Goyal, P.91)

In this research question, the runoff and deep percolation data are of interest. As an overview, here my proposals for the data collection from my last blog:

Irrigation
Data Nursery / Volumetric flow measurement
Precipitation
Precipitation gauge/ meteo data Lupfwig at http://www.agrometeo.ch/de/meteorology/datas
Runoff
Ultrasonic flow meter / Volumetric flow measurement
Change in soil moisture
Tensiometer
Evapotranspiration
Weight measurements
Deep percolation
Required value

Evapotranspiration and soil moisture data should be taken individually according area, plant type, pot size and pot arrangement on the area. (Dumroese, P.194) The optimum irrigation amount must be determined according to the plant type's specific needs. Target is to find the necessary irrigation amount to reach optimum soil humidity and minimum runoff, which will be worked out by comparing the water amounts mentioned above.

Furthermore, for additional research, the collected data could be compared with climate data such as wind velocity, air humidity, radiation and temperature to interpolate a water balance model for optimum irrigation amounts over the year by using meteo data from the region. (Goyal, P.95)

Difficulties


In the irrigation system, there are different nozzles used, and maybe different flows due to pressure differences. So the exact amount of irrigation water will be difficult to evaluate if we don’t have exact flow meters available for measuring.

Also, potential losses in the pipe system could be difficult to measure if we have to work with volumetric measure methods.

If we don’t have access to the different pipes in the inflow areas of the according plant areas, we would have to shift the irrigation hours of the different areas to be able to evaluate the losses of the specific areas.

The evapotranspiration values will be extrapolated, so we wont be able to calculate the exact amounts of water in the system.

If it rains all the time during our project week, we only will be able to make a gross estimation of the losses through and besides the plastic foil, while an optimization of irrigation amounts wont be examinable.

Conclusion


The collected data will reveal leakages in the irrigation system of the tree nursery and show up, if they have used too much water to irrigate during the probation period. It could be used as a base for further investigations concerning the optimum irrigation amount to develop an automatic control of the irrigation system if compared with meteo data and analysed during a longer period.
Our research possibly could help to avoid costs due to water losses and contamination of groundwater and surrounding soil with plant treatment substances while avoiding water stress of the plants.

Literature:


M. R. Goyal, E. W. Harmsen, Evapotranspiration: Principles and applications for water management Apple academic Press, 2014

R.K. Dumroese et al. Nursery manual for native plants: Volume 1: Nursery management U.S. Department of agriculture, 2009 


Mittwoch, 9. März 2016

Blog assignment 1: Research question





Where in the irrigation system of the tree nursery water drops away?

Irrigation optimisation:  where irrigation water could be economised?


Required data:

·         Irrigation amount according to areas
·         Precipitation
·         Terrain division with slopes and  sewers
·         Flow in field-sewers in inflow- and outlet areas
·         Plant type, pot size, pot arrangement
·         Evapotranspiration of the different pot- and planttypes
·         Wind, temperature,  solar radiation
·         Evapotranspiration subsoil

Water loss evaluation


Seepage though/ besides plastic foil

Irrigation water + precipitation water– transpiration – flow sewer inflow-area

leakage pipe system
 flow sewer inflow-area – flow sewer outlet-area

Irrigation optimisation

Soil humidity in pots in the course of a day
Irrigation and precipitation in the course of a day
Flow rate
Optimal irrigation water amount: sufficient humidity in pots with minimal outflow

Needed data set

·         Intra-day  temperature
·         Intra-day  wind velocity
·         Intra-day weight loss div. Pots
·         Intra-day soil humidity in pots
·         Daily precipitation
·         Daily irrigation water amount
·         Intra-day flow sewers inflow and outlet areas

Data Collection


Irrigation amount

Data nursery. Nozzle type and amount, water bills, pump activity. Frequency and time of irrigation.
Calculation irrigation per square meter depeding different areas, plants and pot sizes.
                                                                   

Terrain classification with slopes and  sewers

Data nursery, maps

Precipitation measurement

Precipitation gauges (or raingauges if only liquid precipitation can be measured) are the most common instruments used to measure precipitation. Generally, an open receptacle with vertical sides is used, usually in the form of a right cylinder, with a funnel if its main purpose is to measure rain. Since various sizes and shapes of orifice and gauge heights are used in different countries, the measurements are not strictly comparable (WMO, 1989a). The volume or weight of the catch is measured, the latter in particular for solid precipitation. The gauge orifice may be at one of many specified heights above the ground or at the same level as the surrounding ground. The orifice must be placed above the maximum expected depth of snow cover, and above the height of significant potential insplashing from the ground. For solid precipitation measurement, the orifice is above the ground and an artificial shield should be placed around it. The most commonly used elevation height in more than 100 countries varies between 0.5 and 1.5 m (WMO, 1989a).
The measurement of precipitation is very sensitive to exposure, and in particular to wind.
(World Meteorological Organization, (1989))

Flow rate pipes

To measure the flow rate there are a couple of options. The first would be optical detection. If we can add view ports to your piping and the liquid is not clear it should work. We could use aligned LEDs and photocells for a rough level measurement. Or, even simpler, if there is an access to the pipes, we could measure the water height in the pipe every hour. The next option would be ultrasonic level sensors. I don't know how having multiple on the same line would effect them. If you are just looking for an emergency shut off in case the level drops a single sensor would do.

ExactSonic II - portable ultrasonic flow meter for liquids

This principle of measurement is also referred to as the transit time difference method. For measuring the flow rate of liquids using this technique, ultrasonic pulses are sent and received simultaneously through the medium in the direction of flow and against it. The sensors work alternately as transmitter and receiver. The transit time of the acoustic signals filtered through the medium in the direction of flow is shorter than that against it. The difference in transit time Δt is measured and can be used to calculate the average flow velocity of liquids filtering through the acoustic path. After measuring the flow velocity and with the pipe cross-sectional area, volumetric flow can be calculated.
These ultrasonic flowmeters have many benefits, for example, the measuring instruments produce accurate results in just a matter of minutes, they are easy to install and operate, there is no process interruption and there are no pipe restrictions. As a result, there is no pressure loss and therefore, time and cost savings as the ultrasonic flow meter is easy to install on the pipe.
Advantages of non-invasive measuring with the ultrasonic flowmeters:
  • installation without process interruption or shut-down
  • easy and cost-effective assembly
  • light-weight ergonomic design
  • ideal for use in maintenance areas and commissioning
  • testing fixed measuring equipment
Device-related advantages of the ultrasonic flow measurement equipment compared to other products:
  • no zero point alignment of the flow meter necessary
  • coverage of the most frequent industrial applications for flow measurement of liquids with just two transducer sets
  • high-capacity data logger with numerous parameters for pipe materials and mediums
  • stable and reliable results even under difficult conditions
  • excellent reproducibility of results
Measurement-related advantages of the ultrasonic flow meter:
  • non-contact measurement
  • independent of pressure, temperature, conductivity and viscosity
  • unlimited plant availability, as no process interruption
  • no pressure losses when measuring flow rate, no risk of leakage, no cleaning necessary
  • no mismeasurements as a result of blocked impulse pipes
  • logging of lowest flow velocities (min. 0.2 m/s) resulting in high measuring dynamics
(Hönzsch GMBH (2014))

Weight measurement plants

Continous weighing of pots.
Maybe possible to film analogue scale next to watch during day to have continuous data.

Evapotranspiration subsoil

Weight measurement soil

Continous weighing of a part of soil, packed in tissue and stored in the soil when not weighed in order to be able to calculate a realistic transpiration rate.

Tensiometer (Soil humidity)


A tensiometer is a device for monitoring soil water. It consists of a porous cap (usually made of ceramic with very fine pores) connected to a vacuum gauge.The soil humidity must me measured to be able to calculate the water circles of this area. 
Best would be to install several devices on strategic points of the area and to make continuous measures, which can be compared with the irrigation, flowrate and temperature data.


Temperature, Air humidity

Continuous measuring necessary for comparability of data

Analogue measuring

Stationary measuring on fields with thermometer. Continuous notation by hand.

Data logger for humidity, temperature, air pressure and CO2

·         Continuous data recording over long periods owing to the long battery life and the large data memory.
·         The data loggers can operate in an Ethernet network. The measured data is available in real time and it can be displayed and saved simultaneously on a computer.
·         Maximum reliability of measurement data transmission is guaranteed by the integrated Ethernet interface.
·         Easy evaluation and visualisation of measurement data. The powerful SmartGraph3 software is included in the scope of supply.
·         Local visual and acoustic alarms for fast decisions in the field.
·         Modern enclosure with large display.
(E + E Elektronik Ges.m.b.H (2016))

Wind

Wind velocity is less difficult to measure than atmospheric moisture A number of different whirling cup anemometers are available that either register total miles of wind passed in a given time interval or give continuous records of wind velocity These instruments measure only the average values of the horizontal component of the wind To measure the instantaneous velocities in the major direction as well as those to the right and left and up and down is much more difficult and requires specialized equipment Pressure plate anemometers hot wire anemometers or pressure tube anemographs are generally used for this purpose and the scale and frequency of the fluctuations measured depends upon the inertia of the instrument used The wind measurements required in the evaporation equation can be obtained with standard instruments Wind velocity is measured at two levels with a pair of contacting cup type anemometers Wind direction is measured at the upper level only The type of wind record required depends on the kind of humidity instruments being used If continuous records of atmospheric moisture are being obtained as from dew point recorders or hygro thermographs continuous records of wind velocity will be required in order to determine the rate of evaporation for short tune intervals If however only integrated values of atmospheric moisture are being obtained as from chemical absorption hygrometers continuous records of wind velocity are unnecessary but only an indication of the total miles of wind passed during the time interval for which the moisture measurements apply The fact that the required wind value in the evaporation equation is the difference in velocity at the two levels makes it unnecessary to apply a correction factor to the readings of either instrument Wind velocity enters the formula also in the determination of z zi and here actual velocities are required However failure to apply the small correction factors to get true wind speeds at the two levels will result in errors so small they can be neglected.(Charles Warren (1942))

Literature


World Meteorological Organization, (1989): International Workshop on  Precipitation   Measurements B. Sevruk, ed.)

Hönzsch GMBH (2014). Retrieved from http://www.hoentzsch.com/en/products/ultrasonic-ua/ on 18.03.2016.

E + E Elektronik Ges.m.b.H (2016). Retrieved from http://www.epluse.com/en/products/humidity-instruments/humidity-temperature-logging/humlog20/ on 18.03.2016.
Measurement of Evaporation from Land and Water Surfaces (1942) by Charles Warren Thornwaite,Benjamin Holzman